Casey grew up in Guymon, OK. He attended Oklahoma Panhandle State University (OPSU), where he received his Bachelor of Music Education with an emphasis in Instrumental Education. While attending OPSU, he met the love of his life, Leigh Ann. They were married on July 31st, 1999. Leigh Ann holds a Bachelor of Elementary Education degree from OPSU. She loves to read and cook. They have been blessed with two children: Caleigh and Caleb.

Casey was saved while attending a children's camp at the age of 7 and was baptized shortly thereafter. He was later called into full-time ministry while attending Falls Creek in 1999. He has served at Grace Southern Baptist Church in Guymon, OK, and First Baptist Church in Cyril, OK before being called to Cheyenne in March, 2012.